Located in the heart of North Bexley, this exceptional residence is set on an extraordinary 1.1± acre lot near Commonwealth Park and Jeffrey Mansion. The expansive grounds create a rare sense of privacy and seclusion, while the home offers 5,341 square feet of beautifully appointed living space, plus a 400± sf finished lower-level recreation room. A welcoming covered front porch opens to an entry foyer and a first floor designed for both entertaining and comfortable everyday living. Formal living and dining rooms are complemented by a den/home office and a dramatic family room with soaring ceilings. At the heart of the home is the expansive eat-in kitchen, completely renovated in 2014 and offering abundant workspace, a pantry, coffee bar/beverage center, and a second dining area perfect for casual meals and family gatherings. The outdoor setting is truly spectacular. The expansive, park-like grounds offer an exceptional sense of privacy. A screened porch overlooks the in-ground pool, completed in 2016, along with an impressive patio and striking stone outdoor fireplace. Whether hosting a summer celebration, a team dinner, enjoying an evening by the fire, or relaxing poolside, this secluded backyard retreat feels like a private resort. A separate side patio provides yet another inviting outdoor escape--an extraordinarily rare setting in Bexley. The second floor features four generously sized bedrooms, three full baths, and laundry. A finished lower-level recreation room with an additional half bath and outdoor access provides even more space for entertaining or accommodating pool guests. Completing the property is a three-car detached garage with a versatile studio above--ideal for a private office or creative retreat. A concrete driveway provides substantial parking. Offering exceptional scale, remarkable privacy, and effortless indoor-outdoor living one mile from Bexley's vibrant Main Street, this distinctive property presents an opportunity unlike any other.
Details
MLS #
226034043
Listing Type
For Sale
Style
House
Sub-Type
Resale
Status
Contingent
Year
1909
Days On Site
24
Listing Provided By
Cutler Real Estate | David S Powers
Features
Bed(s)
4
Bath(s)
5 Total
SQ Feet
5,341
Garage
3
Basement
Y
Acreage
1.10
Taxes
Property
31193
Area Information
State
OH
County
Franklin
City
Bexley
Zip Code
43209
Community Name
North Bexley
School District
BEXLEY CSD 2501 FRA CO.
High School
BEXLEY CSD 2501 FRA CO.
Listing VS Median (in North Bexley)
Price: $2,195,000
low | high
Med: $1,695,000
72.779043280182% of Average
sqft: 5,341
low | high
Med: 4,162
72.074517880547% of Average
$ / sqft: $411
low | high
Med: $407
50.904101431872% of Average
On site: 24
low | high
Med: 70
34.285714285714% of Average
Sourced by Back At You
Market Activity 43209
Date
Sales
Avg $ Per SqFt
Min Sale Price
Max Sale Price
Med Sale Price
Date: Sep 2026
Sales: 1
Avg $ Per SqFt: $
Min Sale Price: $300,000
Max Sale Price: $300,000
Med Sale Price: $300,000
Date: Aug 2026
Sales: 11
Avg $ Per SqFt: $265.15
Min Sale Price: $270,000
Max Sale Price: $775,000
Med Sale Price: $442,000
Date: Jul 2026
Sales: 19
Avg $ Per SqFt: $251.28
Min Sale Price: $110,000
Max Sale Price: $2,185,000
Med Sale Price: $510,000
Date: Jun 2026
Sales: 32
Avg $ Per SqFt: $255.62
Min Sale Price: $267,000
Max Sale Price: $1,350,000
Med Sale Price: $440,000
Date: May 2026
Sales: 40
Avg $ Per SqFt: $273.19
Min Sale Price: $15,000
Max Sale Price: $2,000,000
Med Sale Price: $551,050
Date: Apr 2026
Sales: 30
Avg $ Per SqFt: $265.38
Min Sale Price: $169,900
Max Sale Price: $1,575,000
Med Sale Price: $457,500
Date: Mar 2026
Sales: 30
Avg $ Per SqFt: $289.71
Min Sale Price: $179,000
Max Sale Price: $3,200,000
Med Sale Price: $670,000
Date: Feb 2026
Sales: 17
Avg $ Per SqFt: $240.49
Min Sale Price: $230,000
Max Sale Price: $1,172,000
Med Sale Price: $487,500
Date: Jan 2026
Sales: 12
Avg $ Per SqFt: $221.84
Min Sale Price: $254,000
Max Sale Price: $900,000
Med Sale Price: $348,750
Date: Dec 2025
Sales: 14
Avg $ Per SqFt: $190.51
Min Sale Price: $2,200
Max Sale Price: $1,100,000
Med Sale Price: $347,250
Date: Nov 2025
Sales: 14
Avg $ Per SqFt: $228.88
Min Sale Price: $2,150
Max Sale Price: $1,275,000
Med Sale Price: $423,500
Date: Oct 2025
Sales: 23
Avg $ Per SqFt: $191.78
Min Sale Price: $1,450
Max Sale Price: $672,000
Med Sale Price: $325,000
Sourced by Back At You
Sep 2026
Sales:
1
Avg $ Per SqFt:
$
Min Sale Price:
$300,000
Max Sale Price:
$300,000
Med Sale Price:
$300,000
Aug 2026
Sales:
11
Avg $ Per SqFt:
$265.15
Min Sale Price:
$270,000
Max Sale Price:
$775,000
Med Sale Price:
$442,000
Jul 2026
Sales:
19
Avg $ Per SqFt:
$251.28
Min Sale Price:
$110,000
Max Sale Price:
$2,185,000
Med Sale Price:
$510,000
Jun 2026
Sales:
32
Avg $ Per SqFt:
$255.62
Min Sale Price:
$267,000
Max Sale Price:
$1,350,000
Med Sale Price:
$440,000
May 2026
Sales:
40
Avg $ Per SqFt:
$273.19
Min Sale Price:
$15,000
Max Sale Price:
$2,000,000
Med Sale Price:
$551,050
Apr 2026
Sales:
30
Avg $ Per SqFt:
$265.38
Min Sale Price:
$169,900
Max Sale Price:
$1,575,000
Med Sale Price:
$457,500
Mar 2026
Sales:
30
Avg $ Per SqFt:
$289.71
Min Sale Price:
$179,000
Max Sale Price:
$3,200,000
Med Sale Price:
$670,000
Feb 2026
Sales:
17
Avg $ Per SqFt:
$240.49
Min Sale Price:
$230,000
Max Sale Price:
$1,172,000
Med Sale Price:
$487,500
Jan 2026
Sales:
12
Avg $ Per SqFt:
$221.84
Min Sale Price:
$254,000
Max Sale Price:
$900,000
Med Sale Price:
$348,750
Dec 2025
Sales:
14
Avg $ Per SqFt:
$190.51
Min Sale Price:
$2,200
Max Sale Price:
$1,100,000
Med Sale Price:
$347,250
Nov 2025
Sales:
14
Avg $ Per SqFt:
$228.88
Min Sale Price:
$2,150
Max Sale Price:
$1,275,000
Med Sale Price:
$423,500
Oct 2025
Sales:
23
Avg $ Per SqFt:
$191.78
Min Sale Price:
$1,450
Max Sale Price:
$672,000
Med Sale Price:
$325,000
MLS Number: 226034043
David S Powers – (614) 361-2729 – dpowers@cutlerhomes.com
Cutler Real Estate – (614) 410-5334 – bexleycohatch@cutlerhomes.com
Request a showing
Request a showing
MLS Internet Data Exchange (IDX) information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing, and that the data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by Columbus Realtors
MLS Number: 226034043
David S Powers – (614) 361-2729 – dpowers@cutlerhomes.com
Cutler Real Estate – (614) 410-5334 – bexleycohatch@cutlerhomes.com
